Extra SciTechSpace: HANDS ON: Garmin StreetPilot for iPhone [PICS & VIDEO]

Saturday, January 29, 2011

HANDS ON: Garmin StreetPilot for iPhone [PICS & VIDEO]

Garmin has finally created a navigation app for the iPhone, and now StreetPilot for iPhone is available in the App Store for $40. Heres a review where we compare the iPhone version to another Garmin hardware GPS navigator, the Nuvi 1690.

Ive been using Garmin GPS navigation since the days when the hardware cost $800, and so I was interested in seeing if Garmin could translate the excellent user interface and responsiveness of its hardware navigation units to the iPhone.

Delayed for years because of Garmins foray into its own smartphone hardware, the companys done a respectable job of moving its software onto the iOS platform. A big plus with the software is its continuously updated maps, where small parts of the map software reside on the iPhones hard drive, but most are downloaded vi! a the 3G network.

This can be good and bad. While the maps are the freshest available, if you stray outside AT&Ts 3G network, you might not see a map until you get closer to a 3G tower. However, in my testing in the Milwaukee metropolitan area, this wasnt a problem at all.

Most of the features youll get on Garmin hardware units are there in the software, including extensive points of interest such as gas stations and restaurants, helpful lane assist capabilities, and spoken street names.

In my testing, this iPhone version offered more information, and sooner than its hardware brandmate, a Garmin Nuvi 1690. In some cases, the iPhone version was slower, but as you can see in the video below, the speed difference was slight, and didnt matter as much as the iPhone versions useful tendency of offering additional street names in advance.

On the left of the navigation screen, theres a small iPod icon, and when you select it, you can pause your music, skip to the next song, and go to your iPhones music player to select different playlists and songs. Unfortunately, its not as friendly with Pandora Radio, where if you try to listen to Pandora music, as soon as the voice kicks in, Pandora is gone for good.

Some users have complained about the sound quality of the voices in the iPhone StreetPilot, but thats been improved with the recent update, although the sound quality of the voices is still not as good as that of the hardware versions. This seems like it would be an easy thing to fix, but in my testing, the voices were still clearly audible. You can hear the difference in the video below.

Overall, Garmin has done an admirable job of bringing its elegant user interface to the iPhone. The softwares $40 price is reasonable, especially since it includes live updates of road conditions and the freshest possible maps. However, given the unpredictability of AT&Ts network, taking a long trip with its constantly updating maps might be a problem if youre traveling through sparsely pop! ulated a reas. In addition, Id like to see better integration with Pandora, and higher-quality voices.

To get an idea of Garmin StreetPilot for iPhones performance, take a look at this video where you can see which device won my informal and unscientific competition, and then dont miss the gallery where Ive made additional comments and observations.